What should I do with my old 401k? – MPSOS165

Lisa vs the loansA Census Bureau survey shows millennials change jobs every 3.2 years. Many of them saved a little in the company retirement plan in order to get the match. What should they do when they leave the company for bigger and better opportunities? Should they cash it out to fund the move? Should they roll it into a plan with more options?

Lisa Emperador of LisaVsTheLoans.com is a young professional with $8,000 in an old 401(k). She had several options for what to do with the money when starting with a new company.

Lisa has a bunch of debt and could have cashed it out to pay down a car loan or credit card debt. Instead, she chose to roll it into a ROTH IRA managed through Betterment.

Was this the best option? Listen to find out if she is happy with the move or regrets her decision.

 

What could you do with an old 401k?

What should I do with an old 401k?You can’t do anything with a 401k while working for the company. However, you have several options for what you can do after you leave. I recommend you move the money out of the old plan.

Company plans are limited in the number of investing options and you don’t have as much control. Even more importantly is the need to move it into another retirement plan or pay a large amount of income taxes and penalties.

What would you do with an old 401k? Listen to this episode to understand the differences:

Move it into your new company’s 401k

Pro: The easiest way to move money out of one retirement plan into another.

Con: You are limited to only a handful of investing options

Leave it with the financial management company

Pro: Many more investing options. Also an easy way to make the move.

Con: You have to make the investment choices by yourself or hope the person on the phone knows your financial situation

Move it to a self-managed company

Pro: Many, many more investing options. You have more control over the account.

Con: YOU control the account. Investing regrets are just a click of the Enter-button away

Move it to a trading account

Pro: Fun and much more control

Con: You could lose your shirt in trading fees!

Work with your financial advisor

Pro: Many more investing options. Personalized advice. They help make the money transfer into your account.

Con: Fees may be higher.

Disclosure: Please contact a trained professional before making any big financial moves.

 

Links mentioned in this segment:

Note: I have an affiliation with Betterment that also gives you the first month free using this link:

http://betterment.com/invite/stevestewart

https://investor.vanguard.com/mutual-funds/select-funds

https://www.fidelity.com/fund-screener/research.shtml

 

How do the rich get richer?

1) They spend less than they make

2) They work with professionals, consultants, tax experts, and coaches

3) They buy things wisely

4) They do what they say

5) They give

The secret ingredient? They stick to their moneyplan.

Click here to read the entire transcript 

 

Other articles and interviews mentioned:

I was interviewed on the Dadrenaline Podcast.

Jared Easley may have mentioned me a dozen too-many times on an interview on Cash Car Convert.

What’s wrong with getting rid of credit cards? – my article on Liberty Investor.

Keep workin’ your moneyplan like @BizMarkie – my article on Enemy Of Debt.

Please leave your comments below. Have a PRODUCTIVE day!

Written By

Hello. My name is Steve Stewart and I HATE YOUR DEBT MORE THAN YOU. I believe everyone should be rich so they can help others in times of need. Life is too short to be this broke! Let's work together on designing a plan for your house of financial freedom.

I may not be creating personal finance content anymore, but I'm still here to encourage you and maybe even answer a question or two about your money. Don't hesitate to reach out!

More From Author

Dave Ramsey’s Baby Steps explained by a Dave Ramsey Trained Coach

Dave Ramsey’s Baby Steps have helped millions of people organize their finances and begin to…

25 years of Paying Attention - Not Interest: Money Plan SOS episode 202 from November 2025

25 Years of Paying Attention, Not Interest

It’s been 15 years since the launch of this podcast, and 25 years since my…

BEST and WORST of the Money Plan SOS Podcast

If this is the first time you’ve visited Money Plan SOS, you are in luck!…

You May Also Like

25 years of Paying Attention - Not Interest: Money Plan SOS episode 202 from November 2025

25 Years of Paying Attention, Not Interest

It’s been 15 years since the launch of this podcast, and 25 years since my…

BEST and WORST of the Money Plan SOS Podcast

If this is the first time you’ve visited Money Plan SOS, you are in luck!…

What People Learned About Money By Blogging About Money

This is the last episode of the Money Plan SOS podcast. It was only fitting…